American Idol - Top 11

hahaha. miley cyrus? season 9 just officially became a joke.

lee dewyze - love this song. this arrangement was strange, but he sounded pretty good.

paige miles - god, is she STILL here. i really don't like her. love this song. ugh this was boring and (yes, randy) terrible.

tim urban - fuck, did he just try and wink before going to commercial? just... no. can we send him AND miley home? pair of idiots. love this song, but it's been done too much on idol. and he just made it worse. seriously dude. stop.

aaron kelly - ugh, i hate this song. the beginning sounded good, but the rest was really bad.

crystal bowersox - awesome song choice. i would have liked to hear more WORDS, tho. more of the actual song, instead of the riffing at the end. i LOVE the carpet and that she sat down, heh.

michael lynche - surprisingly enough, i did not hate this. but i'm still not exactly a fan.

andrew garcia - meh. i was so bored, i just couldn't pay attention.

katie stevens - i am ashamed to admit that this song is a huge guilty pleasure of mine. she sounded off key the whole time.

casey james - cheesy song, but i love it. and i think he did a really good job.

didi benami - i wanted to like this, but i didn't.

siobhan magnus - hmm, not a fan of this song AT ALL. love the hair and outfit, tho. kinda sick of the high notes. they've gone the route of shrieking.

man, this was SUCH a lame night. worst season ever?


EDIT for the RESULTS:

definitely the right bottom three.

tie for the bottom? send em both home?

wow. simon was hardcore to paige. i like it!