American Idol Top 3

[planet_taters]

per usual, i watched most of the show in mute.

david archuleta:

i absolutely totally and completely LOVE the song 'and so it goes' by billy joel. it is one of my ALL time favorites. i was thrilled that he sang this! and he did a great job too, especially the first bit w/o the music. there was a bit at the end that i didn't care for... he changed it up a bit TOO much. so, quite different from the original, but still well done. AWESOME song choice!

david cook:

love 'first time ever i saw your face'. another great song choice. he started out a bit rough i thought, but did really good overall.

also love 'dare you to move'. it was a bit of a bland performance tho.

hate the last song he did. bad choice producers! really really don't like that song, but he totally rocked it. go david.


as stated previously, david cook for the win.