planet_taters | american idol top 11 (Reply)

i always like it when they do country week. i think it is a really good 'test' for everybody. and randy travis is cool.

michael - like this song, but i don't think it was a good choice for idol.
allison - love this song. i didn't love this performance, but i did like it.
kris - love this song and love Love LOVED this performance! great voice. great originality. awesome.
lil rounds - love this song. okay performance.
adam - no. did not like. (randy jackson's comment about nin was funny, since johnny cash did a cover of their song 'hurt')
scott - i liked what he did with the song, but i still don't care for his voice.
alexis - love the song, but i did not care for this. i think brooke white from last year did way better with it.
danny gokey - i do like his voice, but he tends to get a bit shouty. not the best song choice.
anoop - this was lovely! great voice. great originality. really really liked it.
megan - did not care for. and holy boobage.
matt giraud - i don't really like this song, but i loved this performance. another great job with originality. i love the tone of his voice.

faves: kris and anoop and matt

EDIT for RESULTS:
dude, that group performance was so lip-synched
michael's comment about what his daughter asked him kinda broke my heart
carrie has such an amazing voice
randy travis is such a class act

a bit sad to see alexis go so soon. others should have gone first, but i'm glad they didn't use the judges save.