![[personal profile]](https://www.dreamwidth.org/img/silk/identity/user.png){kind=small}
American Idol - Top 9
Apr. 6th, 2010 09:54 pmi'm so sick of the "themes" that idol does now. bleh.
aaron kelly - his voice just isn't mature enough. needs a lot more time. i loved simon's eyeroll.
katie stevens - kris already did this song this year. and he was awesome. this kinda wasn't.
andrew garcia - ugh, another one behind the judges. that annoys me. as does this whole performance.
michael lynche - didn't david cook do this song? and way better. they really need to stop letting contestants do songs that have already been done before. i don't GET why the judges love mike so much.
crystal bowersox - and yet another kris allen already did. altho i really did like her version here.
tim urban - votefortheworst is having a boom year.
casey james - never heard this song before, and i LOVED it. his vibrato still annoys me, but he had so much emotion and that was great. THIS is what idol is about.
siobhan magnus - boring. but she sounded nice. (not great, but nice)
lee dewyze - okay, so he didn't perform this during the competition, but kris allen DID perform this during the idol tour. i do love lee, but this was fucking strange and not in a good way.
EDIT for RESULTS:
wow, what a wasted save. still have 9 people judges. i hope this screws them in the end. well, no. cuz that probably means it'd be screwing me. but still.
aaron kelly - his voice just isn't mature enough. needs a lot more time. i loved simon's eyeroll.
katie stevens - kris already did this song this year. and he was awesome. this kinda wasn't.
andrew garcia - ugh, another one behind the judges. that annoys me. as does this whole performance.
michael lynche - didn't david cook do this song? and way better. they really need to stop letting contestants do songs that have already been done before. i don't GET why the judges love mike so much.
crystal bowersox - and yet another kris allen already did. altho i really did like her version here.
tim urban - votefortheworst is having a boom year.
casey james - never heard this song before, and i LOVED it. his vibrato still annoys me, but he had so much emotion and that was great. THIS is what idol is about.
siobhan magnus - boring. but she sounded nice. (not great, but nice)
lee dewyze - okay, so he didn't perform this during the competition, but kris allen DID perform this during the idol tour. i do love lee, but this was fucking strange and not in a good way.
EDIT for RESULTS:
wow, what a wasted save. still have 9 people judges. i hope this screws them in the end. well, no. cuz that probably means it'd be screwing me. but still.
